Best-Of Comments Security & Risk Analysis

wordpress.org/plugins/best-of-comments

Best-Of Comments allows users to tag exceptional comments and display a randomly selected list of those comments wherever they choose in their theme.

10 active installs v1.2 PHP + WP 2.5+ Updated Dec 7, 2016
classiccommentsfeaturedhighlight
85
A · Safe
CVEs total0
Unpatched0
Last CVENever
Safety Verdict

Is Best-Of Comments Safe to Use in 2026?

Generally Safe

Score 85/100

Best-Of Comments has no known CVEs and is actively maintained. It's a solid choice for most WordPress installations.

No known CVEs Updated 9yr ago
Risk Assessment

The "best-of-comments" v1.2 plugin exhibits a mixed security posture. While it has a very small attack surface with no apparent AJAX handlers, REST API routes, shortcodes, or cron events, this is overshadowed by significant concerns in its code quality. The complete lack of output escaping (0% properly escaped) is a critical vulnerability, opening the door to cross-site scripting (XSS) attacks on any output rendered by the plugin. Furthermore, the taint analysis reveals two high-severity flows with unsanitized paths, indicating potential vulnerabilities where user-supplied data could be manipulated in unintended ways. The plugin has no recorded vulnerability history, which is a positive indicator of past stability, but this does not mitigate the immediate risks identified in the static analysis. The absence of nonce checks and reliance on a single capability check, while not ideal, are less concerning than the critical output escaping and taint flow issues. Overall, the plugin's strengths lie in its limited attack surface and lack of historical vulnerabilities, but its weaknesses in output sanitization and data handling present a clear and present danger.

Key Concerns

  • 0% output escaping
  • 2 high severity taint flows
  • 0 nonce checks
  • 1 capability check (limited auth)
Vulnerabilities
None known

Best-Of Comments Security Vulnerabilities

No known vulnerabilities — this is a good sign.
Code Analysis
Analyzed Mar 17, 2026

Best-Of Comments Code Analysis

Dangerous Functions
0
Raw SQL Queries
4
7 prepared
Unescaped Output
17
0 escaped
Nonce Checks
0
Capability Checks
1
File Operations
0
External Requests
0
Bundled Libraries
0

SQL Query Safety

64% prepared11 total queries

Output Escaping

0% escaped17 total outputs
Data Flows
2 unsanitized

Data Flow Analysis

3 flows2 with unsanitized paths
<best-of-comments> (best-of-comments.php:0)
Source (user input) Sink (dangerous op) Sanitizer Transform Unsanitized Sanitized
Attack Surface

Best-Of Comments Attack Surface

Entry Points0
Unprotected0
WordPress Hooks 4
filterwp_headbest-of-comments.php:23
actionadmin_menubest-of-comments.php:26
actionedit_commentbest-of-comments.php:27
actionadmin_menubest-of-comments.php:234
Maintenance & Trust

Best-Of Comments Maintenance & Trust

Maintenance Signals

WordPress version tested4.7.32
Last updatedDec 7, 2016
PHP min version
Downloads3K

Community Trust

Rating0/100
Number of ratings0
Active installs10
Developer Profile

Best-Of Comments Developer Profile

David Miller

2 plugins · 60 total installs

84
trust score
Avg Security Score
85/100
Avg Patch Time
30 days
View full developer profile
Detection Fingerprints

How We Detect Best-Of Comments

Patterns used to identify this plugin on WordPress sites during automated security audits and web crawling.

Asset Fingerprints

Asset Paths
/wp-content/plugins/best-of-comments/best-of-comments.php

HTML / DOM Fingerprints

HTML Comments
<!-- This is not currently a featured comment: --><!-- This is currently a featured comment: -->
Data Attributes
name="feature"id="feature"
Shortcode Output
<li>{author}<br/>{comment}</li>
FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions about Best-Of Comments